Responsum: On Printed Megilot (Scrolls of) Esther

Moses Provenzali

1560

Question: . . . When Rabbi Joseph Ottolenghi was visiting this land, he told me that he printed sixteen megillot on parchment prepared for this purpose [i.e., to be used for the scrolls—Ed.]. When I expressed my surprise, he told me that he does not allow anyone to fulfill his obligation by reading from them, although he would find it very…

Please login or register for free access to Posen Library
Register
Already have an account?
Engage with this Source

Creator Bio

Moses Provenzali

1503–1575

Moses Provenzali was one of the greatest Italian talmudic scholars of his time and was at the heart of several controversies. He was severely criticized for his position on the divorce of Samuel Venturozzo (1564)—an issue that divided Italian rabbis—for ruling that the divorce was invalid because it was made under duress. Indeed, the rabbis of Venice forbade him to hold office for three years (although it seems the ruling was not implemented), and many called for his excommunication. However, Provenzali received the support of rabbis of Safed, including Joseph Karo, and continued to serve as chief rabbi of Mantua until his death. Provenzali wrote an approbation for the first edition of the Zohar (Mantua, 1558). He wrote a guide to Hebrew grammar in verse and a geometric treatise, in addition to many responsa, and commentaries on talmudic tractates and on Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed. Many of his writings remain in manuscript.

You may also like

Halakhic Query to David Oppenheim

The incident was as follows: A woman came before me from a backwater Jewish town weeping bitterly over the sins of her youth, as she had been unfaithful to her first husband before she married her…
View Source

Die Pinchasgasse

“What you spend in honor of the holy days, the Lord will richly reward!” says the Talmud, and pious Pinchas granted everything his wife demanded. Clothes for the children and ornaments for herself…
View Source